Quitter le LMNP pour le Paraguay : sortir du piège fiscal avant la réforme en 2026

Leaving LMNP for Paraguay: Escaping the Tax Trap Before the 2026 Reform

For years, the LMNP (Non-Professional Furnished Landlord) status was the preferred tax loophole for French real estate investors. Its major advantage: the accounting depreciation of the property, which allowed for the reduction—or even elimination—of the BIC tax base for 20-30 years. During the depreciation phase, your rental income was virtually tax-exempt. This regime enabled hundreds of thousands of French people to build real estate wealth with almost zero taxation.

But in 2026, the LMNP's golden days are numbered. Reform is on the table: re-integration of depreciation into the capital gains tax calculation, gradual alignment with the LMP regime, tightening of conditions. Even without reform, LMNP taxation is getting heavier year after year. For furnished landlords who have built significant assets, the question arises acutely: should they leave LMNP now and move to Paraguay before the trap closes?

LMNP in 2026: A Regime on Borrowed Time

LMNP Mechanism Reminder

  • Income taxed as BIC (Industrial and Commercial Profits): not as rental income. Advantage: possibility to depreciate the property.
  • Property Depreciation: the acquisition cost of the property (excluding land, ~80-85% of the price) is depreciated over 20-30 years. Result: annual deduction of 3-5% of the property's value from taxable profit.
  • Furniture Depreciation: furniture is depreciated over 5-10 years (faster deduction).
  • Deductible Expenses: loan interest, renovations, insurance, management fees, property tax—in addition to depreciation.
  • Result: for 15-25 years, the taxable BIC profit is close to zero or even zero thanks to depreciation + expenses. Virtually zero taxation on rental income.
  • The "Hidden" Advantage: at the time of sale, capital gains are calculated under the individual real estate capital gains regime (not on the net book value after depreciation). Depreciation is not "recaptured" → double advantage (no income tax AND capital gains calculated without depreciation recapture).

The Threat of the 2025-2026 Reform

The French government and Parliament are actively discussing an LMNP reform. Envisioned measures include:

  • Re-integration of depreciation into the capital gains calculation: this is THE measure that would change everything. Currently, LMNP capital gains are calculated on the acquisition price (not the net book value). If depreciation is re-integrated, capital gains would be calculated on the net book value (price - accumulated depreciation) → much larger base → much heavier capital gains tax.
  • Example: property acquired for €300,000, depreciated by €150,000 over 15 years. Resale value €350,000. Current capital gain: €350,000 - €300,000 = €50,000 (taxed at 36.2% after allowances). Reformed capital gain: €350,000 - €150,000 (net book value) = €200,000 (taxed at 36.2% after allowances = approximately €40,000-€50,000 in additional tax).
  • LMNP/LMP Alignment: the LMP (Professional Furnished Landlord) regime already calculates capital gains on the net book value. Alignment would eliminate the LMNP advantage on sale.
  • Restriction of the micro-BIC allowance: already reduced by the Le Meur 2024 law (from 71% to 50% for unclassified properties). Further reduction is possible.
  • Overall LMNP cap: discussion of a cap on properties or income beyond which LMNP status would no longer be accessible.

Reform Timeline

The 2025 finance law has already incorporated the re-integration of depreciation for furnished tourist accommodation (Airbnb). Extension to long-term furnished rentals (classic LMNP) is the next logical step. Parliamentary discussions are ongoing in 2026. Probability of adoption within 12-24 months: high.

It's a race against time. Every month that passes without action is another month where the tax trap tightens.

Why LMNP is Becoming a Trap

The Cumulative Depreciation Trap

The more you have depreciated, the deeper the trap. Calculation for an LMNP landlord with 3 properties:

Property Acquisition Price Accumulated Depreciation Net Book Value (VNC) Market Value
Lyon Apartment (2012) €200,000 €100,000 €100,000 €280,000
Bordeaux Studio (2015) €120,000 €48,000 €72,000 €160,000
Nantes T2 (2018) €150,000 €40,000 €110,000 €185,000
Total €470,000 €188,000 €282,000 €625,000

Current capital gain (standard LMNP):

  • €625,000 - €470,000 = €155,000 gross capital gain
  • After holding period allowances (properties > 6 years): reduced net capital gain
  • Estimated tax: ~€20,000-€35,000 (19% + 17.2% after allowances)

Capital gain if reform (depreciation re-integration):

  • €625,000 - €282,000 (Net Book Value) = €343,000 gross capital gain
  • Estimated tax: ~€65,000-€95,000 (36.2% after reduced allowances)

Additional cost of the reform: +€45,000-€60,000 in additional tax. This is the price of waiting. The longer you wait, the more accumulated depreciation increases, and the tighter the trap closes.

The Unintentional LMP Trap

Unintentional transition to LMP (Professional Furnished Landlord) is a growing risk. You become an LMP if:

  • Your furnished rental income exceeds €23,000/year AND
  • Your furnished rental income exceeds your other professional income

Consequences of LMP:

  • Social security contributions (SSI) on income (~22-45% depending on base)
  • Capital gains tax calculated on Net Book Value (depreciation recapture) → massive tax
  • Short-term (< 2 years) or long-term (> 2 years) professional capital gain with specific regime
  • Increased declarative complexity

If your rental portfolio has grown and your other income has decreased (transition to consulting, early retirement), you could involuntarily switch to LMP—and the trap closes immediately.

The "Golden Cage" Trap

Many LMNP landlords are in a "golden cage":

  • Rental income is virtually tax-exempt thanks to depreciation → comfortable
  • But selling is costly (capital gains) and will become even more costly if the reform passes
  • Not selling = remaining in a regime that deteriorates year after year
  • Result: paralysis. "I'm not selling because it's too expensive, and I'm not staying because it's getting worse."

Paraguay offers the way out of this golden cage.

The Exit Strategy: Sell BEFORE the Reform and Expatriate

Why Sell Now (2026)

  • Capital gain calculated on acquisition price (not on Net Book Value) = as long as the reform is not voted, you benefit from the favorable regime
  • Holding period allowances: the longer you have held, the higher the allowances (income tax exemption after 22 years, social security contributions after 30 years)
  • Still a buoyant real estate market: prices have not yet corrected massively in most French cities
  • Interest rates: relatively decreasing, buyers regain purchasing power → sustained demand
  • Every month of waiting: = accumulated depreciation that increases = trap that closes if reform passes

LMNP Sale Calculation Under Current Regime

LMNP sales follow the individual real estate capital gains regime:

  • Capital gain = sale price - acquisition price (NOT Net Book Value) - acquisition costs (7.5% flat rate or actual) - renovation costs (15% flat rate if > 5 years or actual)
  • Income tax allowances: 6%/year from the 6th to the 21st year, 4% for the 22nd → total exemption after 22 years
  • Social security contribution allowances: 1.65%/year from the 6th to the 21st year, 1.6% for the 22nd, 9% from the 23rd to the 30th → total exemption after 30 years
  • Rate: 19% income tax + 17.2% social security contributions = 36.2% before allowances
  • Surtax on net capital gains > €50,000: additional 2-6%

Optimal Sequencing

  1. Months 1-3: comprehensive asset audit (capital gain per property, allowances, estimated tax). Launch Paraguayan residency.
  2. Months 3-6: property listing for sale (real estate agent mandate). Preparation for LMNP activity cessation.
  3. Months 6-12: progressive sales. Payment of capital gains taxes (deducted by notary). Receipt of net capital.
  4. Months 12-18: cessation of BIC activity with SIE and URSSAF. Last LMNP tax return. Transfer of tax residency to Paraguay. Reinvestment in Paraguay or via a US LLC.

LMNP Sale as a Non-Resident: Specifics

If you sell AFTER becoming a Paraguayan resident

You can also sell your LMNP properties after moving to Paraguay. Differences:

  • Real estate capital gains still taxable in France (property located in France = France has jurisdiction)
  • Identical rate: 19% + 17.2% social security contributions (non-residents outside the EEA pay social security contributions)
  • Identical holding period allowances
  • Mandatory tax representative: if sale price > €150,000 and seller is resident outside the EEA (Paraguay = outside EEA). Cost: ~0.5-1% of the sale price.
  • Advantage: if the LMNP reform passes while you are in Paraguay, it should not apply retroactively to properties sold before its entry into force—but the risk exists for properties not yet sold.

Cessation of LMNP Activity as a Non-Resident

  • Inform the SIE (Service des Impôts des Entreprises) of the cessation of LMNP activity
  • Last tax return (form 2031 + annexes) within 60 days following cessation
  • Removal from the register of furnished landlords
  • Cessation of SSI contributions if applicable
  • Your French accountant can manage these formalities remotely

Reinvestment in Paraguay: Options for Ex-LMNP

Option 1: Residential Rental Property in Asunción

  • Gross yield: 6-12% (depending on neighborhood and property type)
  • Taxation: 10% IRACIS if via a Paraguayan company
  • Net yield: 5-10% (vs 2-4% net in France after taxes and potential reform)
  • Direct management (you live there) or via a local agency
  • Details: Paraguay real estate service

Option 2: Diversified Financial Portfolio via US LLC

  • Proceeds from LMNP property sales → invested in ETFs, stocks, bonds via US LLC + Interactive Brokers
  • Historical yield: 5-8%/year (diversified stock/bond portfolio)
  • Taxation: 0% in Paraguay (foreign source income via US LLC)
  • No rental management, no renovations, no tenants
  • Immediate liquidity (selling stocks = instant, selling property = months)

Option 3: Luxembourg Life Insurance

  • Capital placed in a Luxembourg contract with FID (see our Luxembourg life insurance guide)
  • 0% capitalization + 0% redemption + 0% transmission (Paraguayan beneficiaries)
  • Asset protection (security triangle) + tailor-made management
  • Ideal for assets > €500,000

Option 4: Combination of PY Real Estate + Financial

The most balanced strategy for an ex-LMNP with €500,000-€2,000,000 in sale proceeds:

  • 50-60% in Paraguayan real estate (rental yield + potential capital gain)
  • 30-40% in a financial portfolio (US LLC or Luxembourg life insurance) (diversification + liquidity)
  • 10% in cash (Mercury Bank, PY account) for current needs

Global Comparison: Staying in LMNP vs. Moving to Paraguay

Scenario 1: LMNP Portfolio €500,000, Rental Income €30,000/year

Criterion Stay in LMNP (France) Move to Paraguay (PY + US LLC reinvestment)
Gross Rental Income €30,000 €30,000 (PY real estate yield 6% on €500k)
LMNP Depreciation (year 10+) ~€12,000 (remaining depreciation) N/A
Taxable BIC ~€10,000 (after depreciation + expenses) N/A
Tax + Social Contributions ~€4,000-€5,000 €3,000 (10% IRACIS PY) + €0 (US LLC)
SSI (if > €23,000) ~€3,000-€5,000 €0
CFE + Property Tax ~€4,000-€7,000 ~€1,000 (impuesto inmobiliario PY)
LMNP Accountant ~€1,500-€2,500 €360 (€30/month PY accounting)
Cost of Living ~€36,000-€55,000 (France) ~€15,000-€22,000 (Asunción)
Total Net Available ~€-25,000 to -€39,500 (!) ~€3,640-€11,640 surplus

The French LMNP landlord with €30,000 in rental income and a French cost of living is often in deficit (rental income does not cover cost of living + taxes). In Paraguay, they have a surplus, thanks to a 60-70% lower cost of living and reduced taxation. And if the landlord adds consulting income via a US LLC (0% in Paraguay), the situation is even more favorable.

Scenario 2: LMNP Portfolio €1.2M, Income €70,000/year, Reform Risk

Option Stay in LMNP + Reform Voted Sell BEFORE Reform + Paraguay
Net Rental Income (after tax) ~€40,000-€50,000/year (reform → reduced depreciation → increased tax) €0 (properties sold, capital reinvested)
Capital Gains on Sale if Sold BEFORE Reform N/A (keeps properties) ~€50,000-€80,000 capital gains tax (favorable current regime)
Capital Gains on Sale if Sold AFTER Reform ~€120,000-€200,000 capital gains tax (depreciation re-integration) N/A (already sold)
Net Capital After Sale N/A ~€1,100,000-€1,150,000
Reinvested Income in PY (6-8% yield) N/A ~€66,000-€92,000/year
PY Taxes (10% IRACIS + 0% US LLC) N/A ~€5,000-€7,000/year
Annual Net ~€40,000-€50,000 (degraded by reform) ~€59,000-€85,000
Capital Gains Savings (vs. selling AFTER reform) — +€70,000-€120,000 saved

Selling BEFORE the reform and reinvesting in Paraguay generates an annual net €20,000-€35,000/year higher AND a capital gains saving of €70,000-€120,000 (difference between current capital gains regime and reformed capital gains regime). Double gain.

LMNP and Non-Resident Status: Can You Keep LMNP from Paraguay?

Technically Yes

LMNP status is linked to the furnished rental activity, not your personal residency. You can retain your French LMNP properties as a Paraguayan non-resident. However:

  • Your BIC income is taxed in France at the minimum non-resident rate (20-30%) + 17.2% social security contributions if applicable
  • Depreciation continues to apply (reduces the BIC base)
  • But depreciation does NOT reduce the minimum non-resident rate which applies to the net result (not the gross)
  • Non-resident LMNP accounting: more complex and more expensive (€2,000-€4,000/year)
  • If LMP switch (income > €23,000 and > other professional income): SSI contributions even for non-residents (+ massive administrative complexity)

But is it rational?

Keeping LMNP from Paraguay means:

  • Paying 37-47% tax on rental income (non-resident rate + social contributions)
  • Potentially undergoing reform (reintegration of depreciation into capital gains)
  • Paying an expensive LMNP accountant to manage remotely
  • Managing properties remotely (agency, works, tenants)
  • Retaining assets in France that expose you to residual French taxation

The net yield after non-resident taxes (1.5-3%) is much lower than the net yield of reinvestment in Paraguay (5-10%). Except for specific cases (properties with high potential capital gains, advantageous ongoing credit), maintaining LMNP from Paraguay is rarely optimal.

Specific pitfalls of LMNP exit

The pitfall of ceasing BIC activity

Ceasing LMNP activity triggers:

  • Immediate taxation of deferred tax profits (carry-forward losses lost if not used)
  • Last tax return within 60 days
  • If LMP: taxation of latent capital gains on assets listed in the balance sheet (stock of goods)
  • If LMNP: no taxation of latent capital gains upon cessation (capital gains calculated only upon actual sale of the property)

Crucial distinction: in LMNP, you can cease BIC activity and then sell the properties gradually without triggering capital gains at the time of cessation. In LMP, cessation can trigger immediate taxation. Verify your status with your accountant.

The pitfall of early credit repayment

If your LMNP properties are financed by credit:

  • The sale leads to early repayment of the loan
  • Early repayment penalty (IRA): maximum 6 months of interest or 3% of the remaining capital (the lower of the two)
  • Include the IRA in your exit calculation
  • If your credit rate is very low (< 2%), the IRA is often modest

The pitfall of unreported BIC deficits

In LMNP, non-professional BIC deficits can be carried forward against BIC income for the next 10 years. If you cease the activity, unused deficits are lost. If you have significant carry-forward deficits, try to use them before cessation (by reducing depreciation in the year of cessation or temporarily increasing BIC income).

The pitfall of an ongoing lease

If your properties are rented (1-year furnished lease), the sale must respect the tenant's notice period:

  • Notice to quit for sale: 3 months before lease end (furnished) or 6 months (unfurnished)
  • Tenant's right of pre-emption if notice to quit for sale
  • Alternative: sell with tenant in place (legal but 5-15% discount on price)
  • Plan the sale according to lease deadlines

The ecosystem for LMNP exit to Paraguay

Conclusion

LMNP has been the French real estate investor's best friend for two decades. Accounting depreciation has allowed for almost tax-free rental income and wealth building at a lower tax cost. But in 2026, this regime is living its last days: the reintegration of depreciation into the capital gains calculation is under active discussion, social security contributions are expanding, and the risk of involuntary switch to LMP is increasing.

Paraguay offers the optimal exit strategy: sell your LMNP properties BEFORE the reform (capital gains calculated on the acquisition price, not the net book value = saving €70,000-€120,000 on a €1.2M portfolio), expatriate, and reinvest in an environment where the net return is 2-3x higher (6-10% net in Paraguay vs 2-4% net in France).

For a landlord with €500,000 in LMNP assets, exiting to Paraguay transforms a sometimes deficit balance sheet (rental income absorbed by taxes + French cost of living) into a surplus balance sheet (€60,000-€85,000 net/year with PY reinvestment + US LLC). For a €1.2M portfolio, the annual net benefit exceeds €20,000-€35,000/year — not including the capital gains tax savings.

The optimization window is open — but it won't remain so indefinitely. Each additional month of depreciation adds to the potential trap of the reform. The time to act is now.

Are you an LMNP landlord considering Paraguay? Contact our team for a personalized exit audit: capital gains calculation per property, optimal sales timing, reinvestment strategy in Paraguay, cessation of BIC activity, US LLC creation. Your real estate assets deserve the best exit — not the most taxed.

Back to blog

A question? Write to us